Icelanders overthrow top power holders responsible for economic crisis (Kitchenware Revolution), 2008-9

Goals

1) Resignation of the prime minister and cabinet, 2) Resignation of the board of the Central Bank, 3) Resignation of the board of the Financial Security Authority, and 4) New elections as soon as possible

Time period

October, 2008 to February, 2009

Country

Iceland

Location City/State/Province

Reykjavik
Jump to case narrative

Methods in 1st segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak

Methods in 2nd segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak
  • "Away with the government!"

Methods in 3rd segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak
  • "Away with the government!"

Methods in 4th segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak
  • "Away with the government!"

Methods in 5th segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak
  • "Away with the government!"
  • Banging pots
  • in a public square in Reykjavik every Saturday

Methods in 6th segment

  • Hordur Torfason stood in public square with open microphone, inviting passerbys to speak
  • "Away with the government!"
  • Protesters threw red paint onto government building
  • Banging pots
  • Protesters surround the Reykjavik Althingi House (Parliament)
  • Protesters throw eggs and yogurt at government officials and police

Segment Length

21 days

Leaders

Hordur Torfason, Raddir Folksins (organization)

Partners

Not known

External allies

Aftaka, Icelandic anarchist collective

Involvement of social elites

Johanna Sigurdardottir (the popular interim Prime Minister)

Opponents

Right-wing Government of Iceland, Police

Nonviolent responses of opponent

Not known

Campaigner violence

Protesters threw rocks, several of which injured policemen. This was not sanctioned by the leadership of the campaign.

Repressive Violence

The police responded to protests with pepper spray and tear gas.

Cluster

Economic Justice

Classification

Change

Group characterization

Icelandic citizens

Groups in 1st Segment

Hordur Torfason and Raddir folksins

Groups in 2nd Segment

Icelandic citizens

Groups in 5th Segment

anarchists

Groups in 6th Segment

Johanna Sigurdardottir

Additional notes on joining/exiting order

According to the Icelandic anarchist collective Aftaka, anarchists were trying to subvert the government in other ways, but the "'ordinary' citizens" and anarchists joined together during the January 20th protest

Segment Length

21 days

Success in achieving specific demands/goals

6 out of 6 points

Survival

1 out of 1 points

Growth

3 out of 3 points

Total points

10 out of 10 points

Notes on outcomes

The group that started the protests (Raddir folksins) clearly survived, and the movement grew from one person (Hordur Torfason) to 10,000 at its height. All four demands were met.

Database Narrative

At the dawn of the financial crisis, Iceland was controlled by the Independent Party, a right-wing party with decidedly neo-liberal economic policies. Over the past 19 years, banks had been privatized, regulations cut, and the corporate tax rate lowered to 18%. Personal income tax, on the other hand, was held at 36%, regardless of income. As global concern over bank failures grew, the Icelandic government continued to assure citizens that all was well. However, in September 2008, the Icelandic bank Glitner failed, followed closely by the remaining Icelandic banks, Landsbanki and Kaupthing. In October, there was growing discontent in Iceland as the financial crisis plunged a nation with historically negligible unemployment rates into 18% unemployment.

The first protest of the government's handling of this crisis came in mid-October, when a locally well-known singer and song-writer, Hordur Torfason, stood out in a public square in Reykjavik with an open microphone, inviting passersby to speak. The following Saturday was the first organized protest. This protest was better attended, but the event was dominated by one speaker and one view on the financial crisis, and Torfason saw a need to incorporate all voices. On the third Saturday, the campaign took more definite shape, as the organization Raddir Folksins (Voices of the People) was formally established. This demonstration led to the creation of four key demands that defined the campaign: 1) Resignation of the government (the prime minister and cabinet), 2) Resignation of the Central Bank's board, 3) Resignation of the Financial Security Authority's board, and 4) New elections as soon as possible.

The protests continued every Saturday throughout November and December, gaining support. The next development happened on the last day of December, when a group of protesters gathered outside a hotel where a TV special was being broadcast. Political party leaders were being filmed discussing the year's accomplishments. Protesters initially tried to disrupt the broadcast with noise from pots and light from torches, but after this failed, they climbed the fence into the hotel to pull apart and burn the TV cables. This successfully disrupted the broadcast.

The campaign suddenly escalated on January 20, 2009, when around 2,000 people gathered outside the Althingi House (Parliament Building). The protesters banged pots and pans in order to disrupt the meeting of Parliament, which is why the campaign gained the name "The Kitchenware Revolution." Protesters also threw eggs, skyr (a type of Icelandic yogurt), and rocks, breaking several windows. The police used pepper spray to suppress crowds and made over 30 arrests. However, the protesters stayed by the Parliament building into the night, using nearby wood and even a large display Christmas tree to build bonfires.

The following day, on January 21, a crowd surrounded Prime Minister Geir Haarde's official car, throwing eggs and snowballs. That same day, one group threw red paint on a government building. On the night of January 22, tensions came to a head when protesters threw rocks into the Parliament building and injured several policemen. In response, the Icelandic police used tear gas for the first time in 60 years. Throughout the week, protesters maintained noise demonstrations and bonfires in the streets. At the height of the protests, around 10,000 Icelandic citizens were involved, an impressive number considering Iceland's total population of 320,000.

On January 23, Prime Minister Haarde announced that new elections would be held in May and that he would not be running, resigning himself and his entire cabinet. The next day, the Minister of Commerce Bjorn Sigurdsson resigned, as did the Director and board of the Financial Supervisory Board. Participants in the campaign rejoiced, as three of the four demands had been met. However, leaders of the campaign acknowledged that greater reforms of the Icelandic government were necessary. The board and director of the Central Bank remained untouched. With an interim government in place and elections scheduled for May, Raddir Folksins temporarily ceased its Saturday demonstrations.

However, the protesters only skipped one Saturday protest. The following Saturday, February 8, saw protesters gathered in front of Parliament once more, calling for the resignation or firing of the three Governors of the Central Bank's Board. Hordur Torfason urged protesters to meet the next day at the Central Bank Building. That night, the acting Prime Minister Johanna Sigurdardottir also expressed disappointment that the Governors had refused to step down. On February 9, a crowd of activists blocked the entrance to the Bank building, preventing bank chiefs from getting in. One chairman, Ingimundur Fridriksson, agreed to resign. However, the remaining two chairmen, David Oddsson and Eirikur Gudnason, still refused to yield to protesters' demands. 

During the continuing protests in February, the Icelandic Parliament was crafting a law to reform the Central Bank. The amendments to the Central Bank Act would abolish the current Board of Governors of the Central Bank and replace these positions with one Governor and one Deputy Governor. As the passage of this new law became politically inevitable, Oddsson and Gudnason realized they would soon be forced to resign. Instead, both Governors chose to step down on February 26, 2009. On February 27, the amendments to the Central Bank Act passed, and a new Governor and Deputy Governor were chosen. At last, all four of the Icelandic protesters' demands were met.

Influences

This campaign is thought to be the first protest of a government's handling of the financial crisis, possibly influencing later similar protests in Europe. (2)

Sources

"A Statement from the Icelandic Anarchist Collective Aftaka on the Recent Collapse of the Icelandic Government." Anarchy Library 31 Jan. 2009. Web. <http://anarchyfiles.wordpress.com/tag/iceland-protests>.

“Central Bank Bill Becomes Law.” IceNews 27 Feb. 2009: n. page. Web.

“David Oddsson Just Will Not Quit.” IceNews 9 Feb. 2009: n. page. Web.

Dobson, Tim. "Iceland: Protests Bring Down Government." Green Left 30 Jan. 2009 : n. pag. Web.

Erlingsdottir, Iris. "Iceland is Burning." Huffington Post World 20 Jan. 2009 : n. pag. Web.

“Heads of Iceland Central Bank say Goodbye.” IceNews 26 Feb. 2009: n. page. Web.

Henley, Jon. "Iceland Has an Unlikely New Hero." The Guardian 30 Nov. 2008 : n. pag. Web.

"Iceland: A Nation in Revolt." Frontline Vol. 2 Issue 9 March 2009 : n. pag. Web.

"Iceland's Minister of Commerce and board and director of FSA resign." IceNews 25 Jan. 2009 : n. pag. Web.

“Iceland's Oddsson out, Norwegian consultant in.” CentralBanking.com 27 Feb. 2009: n. page. Web.

Lakey, George. "Viking Economics." Melville House Books. 2016.

Moody, Jonas. "Global Financial Crisis Claims Iceland." Time World 26 Jan. 2009 : n. pag. Web.

Sigmundsdottir, Alda. "We Need Far More Radical Changes." The Iceland Weather Report 4 Feb. 2009 : n pag. Web.

Name of researcher, and date dd/mm/yyyy

Dinah DeWald, 26/02/2012