Israelis campaign for affordable housing, better economic life ("Tentifada"), 2011

Goals

Protestors wanted "affordable housing, lower prices, higher taxes on the rich, and better childcare"

Time period notes

The campaign slowed as the summer ended and the government responded to their demands, but all protestors did not leave the city until early winter.

Time period

14 July, 2011 to November, 2011

Country

Israel

Location City/State/Province

Tel Aviv

Location Description

The campaign began in Tel Aviv but spread to numerous cities across the nation.
Jump to case narrative

Leaders

Daphni Leef

Partners

Israeli National Students Union, Histadrut trade union

External allies

Tel Aviv Municipality

Involvement of social elites

Mayor Ron Huldai, MK Miri Regev (Likud), MK Issac Herzog (Labor), MK Nitan Horovitz (Meretz)

Opponents

Some politicians in the government opposed negotiations

Nonviolent responses of opponent

None known

Campaigner violence

None known

Repressive Violence

None known

Cluster

Economic Justice

Classification

Change

Group characterization

students
pensioners
workers
teachers
Middle-class citizens
young parents

Groups in 1st Segment

Bnei Akiva students
Beersheba
Rupin College
BeitBerl College
Tel Hai College

Segment Length

25 days

Success in achieving specific demands/goals

4 out of 6 points

Survival

1 out of 1 points

Growth

3 out of 3 points

Total points

8 out of 10 points

Database Narrative

On 14 July 2011, Daphni Leef, a freelance filmmaker, began a campaign to be known as the “Tent Revolt” or “Tentifada.” Leef, like many middle-class citizens in Tel Aviv and in the nation of Israel, faced great financial hardships in an economy that statistically should have provided a level of comfort. Barely able to afford her home, Leef created a Facebook page, inviting those with similar grievances to pitch tents on Rothschild Boulevard in Tel Aviv Thursday of that week in order to convince the government to lower housing costs. 

Quickly, three-dozen tents arose on the boulevard, and the purpose of the campaign expanded, as they “called for affordable housing, lower prices, higher taxes on the rich, and better childcare.” Within the tent city they held debating circles, prayer services, karaoke nights, and other events and activities to promote community and incite discussion. Every evening they met to decide what to do next and then deliver their decisions and expand the movement using Facebook, Twitter, and email. Local restaurants and many residents in Tel Aviv provided them with food and other amenities. 

The Tel Aviv Municipality gave the protestors a permit to allow continued legal occupation. Tel Aviv Mayor Ron Huldai had initially spoken out in opposition of the protest but later stated that it was “appropriate and justified.” Despite his later concession to the movement, when he visited the tent city he was greeted with jeers by the protestors. MK Miri Regev (Likud) received the same greeting, but MK Isaac Herzog (Labor), and MK Nitan Horovitz (Meretz) both received “warm” welcomes.

The movement rapidly spread across the country while it continued to grow in Tel Aviv. Bnei Akiva students joined in the original city. Rupin College in Netanya, Beit Berl College in Sharon, and Tel Hai College in Kiryat Shmona all joined the campaign, as well. In Kikar Zion, Jerusalem, protestors established another tent city. 

The Histadrut trade union vocally supported the protestors, as did the Israeli National Students Union. The protest grew to 300,000, with 3,300 tents in several cities.  In a survey, 90% of Israeli citizens spoke in favor and solidarity with the protestors. 

On 23 July 2011, the Facebook page called for a mass demonstration in numerous cities. Protestors nationwide marched and waved banners and signs to call further attention to the movement. Signs read, “Summer of discontent,” “Yes, we tent,” “Tentifada,” and “Long live the revolution.” 

Finally, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu requested that the Knesset Economics Committee meet in order to alter the national housing bill passed recently. This would then require that construction on projects begin within two and a half years of the approval. He attempted to pass a bill through that would provide affordable housing but it failed.

More rallies occurred in cities throughout the country on 30 July
and 6 August. In response, about 100 Tel-Aviv residents opposed to the movement
launched a counter-protest through Rothschild Boulevard, calling the tent-city
protesters' methods anarchist. The two groups later met for peace talks.

On 8 August, Netanyahu then created a committee of fourteen economists, academics, and officials headed by Tel Aviv University professor of economics Manuel Trajtenberg. The committee would study the situation, draw up a plan, and present it to the 16 minister socioeconomic cabinet, and then that cabinet would provide recommendations to the actual government.

On 22 August and 26 August, protesters occupied abandoned buildings
before being removed by police. 
The Israeli government responded to the encampments and occupations
further on 6 September 2011, forcibly evacuating the tent-city. Protesters
verbally insulted police as this occurred, and a protesters at city hall became
violent, throwing eggs and charging the doors. Police arrested over 30
demonstrators. 

Near the end of the month, on 27 September, the tent-city protesters
held a press conference to give Netanyahu an ultimatum until 29 October to
provide clear plans for addressing the social justice issues they raised. When
this goal was not met, demonstrators returned to the streets for rallies,
smaller than those from the previous summer

Eventually a small portion of the requested reforms were made, thus improving the public education system and slightly improving housing costs through a program that promoted the construction of affordable housing projects. 

As demands were met, though not necessarily to the satisfaction of all the protestors, tents began to disappear across the country. Other pressing concerns became the primary issues and the campaign ended. Nevertheless, the campaign left a mark as being one of the first nonviolent campaigns unassociated with the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. 

Influences

The "Cottage Cheese Intifada," a Facebook initiated boycott inspired them to begin their own. This was owns of the first major protests in Israel not concerned with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. (1)

Sources

Buck, Tobias. "Israel's Middle- Class Revolt Hits Fresh Peak." FT.com. Financial Times, 12 Aug. 2011. Web. 24 Mar. 2013. <http://www.ft.com/>.

Connolly, Kevin. "Israel Suffers Summer of Economic Discontent." BBC News. British Broadcasting Corporation, 08 Feb. 2011. Web. 24 Mar. 2013. <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-14344515>.

Hartman, Ben. "Protest Leaders Call for All Tent Cities to Mass in TA." JPost.com. The Jerusalem Post, 21 July 2011. Web. 24 Mar. 2013. <http://www.jpost.com/>.

Hartman, Ben. "Revolt Over Rent Launched in Tel Aviv" JPost.com. The Jerusalem Post, 16 July 2011. Web. 24 Mar. 2013. <http://www.jpost.com/>.

Hellman, Ziv. "Trajtenberg's Taxing Task." JPost.Com. The Jerusalem Post, 29 Aug. 2011. Web. 24 Mar. 2013. <http://www.jpost.com/>.

Name of researcher, and date dd/mm/yyyy

Jessica Seigel and Fatimah Hameed, 24/03/2013