Syrian activists protest for inclusion at Geneva II conference in Switzerland, 2014

Goals

To pressure the UN to uphold Security Council resolutions 1325, 1820, 1888, 1889, 1960, 2106, 2122; guarantee at least 30% representation of Syrian women during the entire Geneva II negotiation process; include Syrian women's and civil society groups participation as observers in negotiations; ensure that Syrian women are present in the transitional government process, including the constitutional drafting committee and drafting of election law; appoint a Syrian gender advisor to mediation team.

Time period

11 January 2014 to 24 January 2014

Country

Switzerland

Location City/State/Province

Geneva, Switzerland
Jump to case narrative

Methods in 3rd segment

Methods in 4th segment

Additional methods (Timing Unknown)

Segment Length

Approximately 2.3 days

Notes on Methods

Method note for “alternative social institutions” in the 1st, 5th, and 6th segment:
The organization of an alternative conference and conference planning meetings. As a response to the exclusion of civil society and women from the official UN peace talks, activists designed an adjacent yet oppositionary system that created opportunity for previously-denied participation. Although the organizers did not intend for this alternative conference to maintain itself long-term, its existence demonstrated that power existed outside of exclusionary institutions.

Leaders

UN Women; Women Lead to Peace; CodePink; MADRE; Women's International League for Peace and Freedom; Medea Benjamin, CodePink co-founder; Jodie Evans, CodePink co-founder

Partners

Kvinna till Kvinna Foundation, Karama, Nobel Women's Initiative

External allies

Governments of Finland, Norway, the Netherlands, European Union

Involvement of social elites

Mairead Maguire, Shirin Ebadi, Ann Wright, Chris Hedges, Alice Walker, Geena Davis

Opponents

Organizers of the Geneva II conference, in particular: Lakhdar Brahami, UN-Arab League Joint Special Representative for Syria; Ban Ki-moon, UN Secretary-General

Campaigner violence

Not known

Repressive Violence

Not known

Cluster

Democracy
Peace

Classification

Change

Groups in 1st Segment

UN Women
Department of Political and Peacekeeping Affairs
European Union
Governments of Finland, Norway, and the Netherlands

Groups in 4th Segment

Syrian National Coalition

Groups in 5th Segment

CodePink
Kvinna till Kvinna Foundation
Karama
MADRE
Nobel Women's Initiative
Social elites: Mairead Maguire, Shirin Ebadi, Ann Wright, Chris Hedges, Alice Walker, Geena Davis

Segment Length

Approximately 2.3 days

Success in achieving specific demands/goals

2 out of 6 points

Survival

1 out of 1 points

Growth

3 out of 3 points

Total points

6 out of 10 points

Database Narrative

In March 2011, civilian protests against the ruling Assad regime resulted in violent government suppression and a Syrian civil war. Primarily, civilians suffered the fallout of conflict between the government and armed resistance groups, many of whom formed rivalries with one another. Three years later, with no end of war in sight and only one unsuccessful UN conference in 2012, a peace envoy to Syria, Lakhdar Brahimi, intended the 2014 Geneva II conference to facilitate a transitional government agreement between the Syrian government and its opposition. The agenda notably excluded both civil society and women.

Eleven days before the Geneva II conference, UN Women – a UN sub-organization focused on gender equality – hosted a two-day conference from 11 January to 12 January. Around 50 Syrian women convened to discuss strategy to secure inclusion in Geneva II, to share experiences, and to establish a list of demands. The activists organized their demands on three tiers: the overall strategy plan for ending the civil war, the negotiations structure, and women’s involvement in peace processes. The latter tier was the focus of this particular campaign, although the activists were also driven by the broader grand strategy of obtaining a ceasefire and democratic government. Lakhdar Brahimi, UN-Arab League Joint Special Representative for Syria, attended the womens’ conference on 11 January, and he agreed to meet with them again on 14 January to review the conference’s Outcome Document.

On 13 January, UN Women released a press statement created by the women at the conference. Their demands were multi-level, but their priority was to pressure the UN to uphold Security Council resolutions 1325, 1820, 1888, 1889, 1960, 2106, 2122; to guarantee at least 30% representation of women during the entire negotiation process; to include women's and civil society groups participation as observers in negotiations; to ensure that women are present in the transitional government process, including the constitutional drafting committee and drafting of election law; to appoint a Syrian gender advisor to the mediation team; and to ensure that negotiating parties adopt the Outcome Document. Their longer-term objectives were to obtain a ceasefire, lift the siege on humanitarian aid, and guarantee equal citizenship to all Syrians regardless of ethnic identity. 

The Syrian National Coalition agreed, after much internal debating, to attend the Geneva II talks. In the end, 58 members supported attendance, 14 opposed, and 44 had already withdrawn from the vote. Several members were not enthused due to their beliefs that the conversation would go nowhere; others believed that attending the talks would further lower their approval by Syrian rebel groups.

Despite Brahimi’s attendance at the UN Women conference and nominal statements on the importance of the female perspective, he failed to secure any women a role beyond observer, which meant that the women representatives could only observe, and not engage in, negotiation discussions at the UN conference. In response, the Women Lead to Peace coalition organized a five-day summit. This coalition consisted of multinational women’s and civil society groups, such as the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF), CodePink, and MADRE. Following coordination meetings the day prior, the official summit began with an alternative peace talk at the Geneva Graduate Institute on 21 January. Eighty women gathered, several of whom shared their experiences with gendered peace negotiations in Northern Ireland and Bosnia. The event was live-streamed for maximum exposure, although no mainstream media outlets attended, and very few embassy or UN staff came. 

On 22 January, from 10am to 12pm, Women Lead to Peace staged a demonstration in front of the media/delegate entrance of Montreux Palace, while the official UN negotiations commenced inside. The participants carried banners with signs that read, "Guys, Put Down Your Guns!" "No Peace Without Women at the Peace Table" "Aid, Not Weapons” and “Save Syria.” Some women wore black veils and white masks to create imagery of death and mourning; others displayed mock gravestones. The coalition organized a banner drop and street theater as well.

While the 11 to 12 January conference had involved primarily Syrian activists, by 20 January, participants included Nobel Peace Prize laureates Mairead Maguire (Northern Ireland) and Shirin Ebadi (Iran), as well as former U.S. diplomat Ann Wright. At this point, the demonstrators had garnered significant international attention and the vocal endorsement of U.S. journalist Chris Hedges, U.S. author Alice Walker, and U.S. actress Geena Davis. 

On 24 January, the Women Lead to Peace participants rallied in front of Geneva’s UN headquarters and delivered a mass petition to Brahimi and Ban Ki-moon, the UN Secretary-General. During the official peace negotiations, the campaign did succeed on a few fronts. The campaign sent ten Syrian women  as delegates to meet with UN officials, while the WILPF facilitated a meeting between activists and Samantha Powers, U.S. delegate to the UN. 

Although some peace representatives engaged in peripheral conversations with negotiators, only five women were present at the official negotiations. Two women were part of the Syrian National Coalition, and the other three provided technical assistance. The few women who sat at the table ultimately represented opposition to the Assad regime, not the non-violent and gendered perspective championed by Women Lead to Peace. Upon the conclusion of the Geneva II conference, most state actors and delegates acknowledged that they did not succeed in reaching an agreement or making significant progress towards a peace resolution. The campaign did not succeed in any of its goals besides securing more female observers.

Sources

Attendance at Women's Conference on Peace in Syria, Geneva (Switzerland) for Jan. 22, 2014. Ann Wright Papers (Box 17). SCPC-DG-285. Swarthmore College Peace Collection, https://archives.tricolib.brynmawr.edu//repositories/8/archival_objects/865907.

Benjamin, Medea. 2014. "Should Syria's Future Be Decided by Men With Guns?" CodePink, 21 January. Retrieved 2 October 2024 (https://www.codepink.org/should_syria_s_future_be_decided_by_men_with_guns).

Butler, Maria. 2014. "UN Peace Talks on Syria Collectively Failed Women." PassBlue, 10 February. Retrieved 26 September 2024 (https://www.passblue.com/2014/02/10/un-peace-talks-on-syria-collectively-failed-women/).

CodePink. 2014. "Women Make Demands, Demonstrate During Syrian Peace Talks." 22 January. Retrieved 3 October 2024 (https://www.popularresistance.org/women-make-demands-demonstrate-during-syrian-peace-talks/).

France24. 2014. "Main Syrian Opposition Agrees to 'Geneva 2' Peace Talks." Retrieved 1 October 2024 (https://www.france24.com/en/20140118-syria-opposition-agrees-peace-talks).

Laub, Zachary. 2023. "Syria's Civil War: The Descent Into Horror." Council on Foreign Relations, 14 February. Retrieved on 30 September 2024 (https://www.cfr.org/article/syrias-civil-war).

Syria, 1937-2021. Collected Document Group: Category B, SCPC-CDG-B. Swarthmore College Peace Collection, https://archives.tricolib.brynmawr.edu//repositories/8/archival_objects/805118.

UN Women Arab States. n.d. "Supporting Syrian Women’s Engagement in the Syrian Political Process: Building a Constituency for Peace." Retrieved 3 October 2024 (https://arabstates.unwomen.org/en/what-we-do/peace-and-security/syria-wps-programme).

UN Women. 2014. "Press Release: Conference of Syrian Women, Convened by UN Women and the Netherlands, Ends with Strong Recommendations for Upcoming Peace Talks." 13 January. Retrieved 1 October 2024 (https://www.unwomen.org/en/news/stories/2014/1/press-release-on-syrian-women-meeting).

UN Women. 2014. "Syrian Women’s Joint Statement on Engagement in the Syrian Political Process." 13 January. Retrieved 30 September 2024 (https://www.unwomen.org/en/news/stories/2014/1/statement-by-syrian-women-in-geneva).

UN News. 2014. "Syria: UN-sponsored conference demands full voice for women in seeking to end crisis." United Nations, 13 January. Retrieved 1 October 2024 (https://news.un.org/en/story/2014/01/459572).

Additional Notes

The democracy tag refers to the effort for female democratic participation throughout the campaign, particularly in relation to representation in the transitional government.

Name of researcher, and date dd/mm/yyyy

Peyton Davis, 09/10/2024