Cornell University students sit-in for divestment from apartheid South Africa, 1985

Goals

University divestment from South Africa by removing funds from companies doing business with the apartheid regime.

Time period

18 April, 1985 to 11 May, 1985

Country

United States

Location City/State/Province

Ithaca, New York

Location Description

Cornell University campus
Jump to case narrative

Leaders

Cornell students Matthew Lyons, Kelly McGowan, and Joan Meyers; Cornell professor David Lyons

Partners

South African Divestment Coalition (SADC), Faculty and Staff Against Apartheid (FSAA), various student groups

External allies

Not known

Involvement of social elites

Not known

Opponents

Cornell University Board of Trustees

Nonviolent responses of opponent

Not known

Campaigner violence

Not known

Repressive Violence

Arrests

Cluster

Economic Justice
Human Rights

Classification

Change

Group characterization

Cornell University students
faculty
Staff

Groups in 1st Segment

Cornell University students
South African Divestment Coalition
Faculty and Staff Against Apartheid

Groups in 2nd Segment

Cornell University faculty and staff

Groups in 3rd Segment

Student groups

Segment Length

4 days

Success in achieving specific demands/goals

2 out of 6 points

Survival

0.5 out of 1 points

Growth

2 out of 3 points

Total points

4.5 out of 10 points

Notes on outcomes

Despite widespread support across the campus community, Cornell’s Board of Trustees declined to divest completely from South Africa. However, they did adopt a policy of selective divestment that continued until the collapse of the apartheid government in 1990.

Many of the students remained active in the campaign for divestment throughout the fall of 1985 and into the next year. However, with the Board of Trustees refusing to divest further, many students stopped actively campaigning for the cause.

Over the course of the campaign, the number of students involved increased from a couple hundred to a couple thousand and both faculty and staff had joined the movement. However, there was limited organization within the group and few known external allies offered their support.

Database Narrative

By the mid-1980s, the Apartheid regime had been in control of South Africa for nearly 40 years. The country was in the midst of a national crisis, had declared a state of emergency, and over 5,000 people had been killed by the violence. Despite the African Nation Congress’ requests for international aid, specifically in the form of divestment, the United States (as well as many other powerful countries) resisted. Divestment - a form of economic boycott used to pressure a government, industry, or company towards a change in policy - was seen as too costly of an economic risk by many United States businesses.

However, divestment did have some support, especially among students at universities around the country. Proponents of divestment believed that if universities cut their financial ties to South Africa, the apartheid government would feel pressured to end their discriminatory practices. In the spring of 1985, during the height of the divestment movement, students at Cornell University held a sit-in (beginning on April 18) to urge the Board of Trustees to reconsider their investment policies in South Africa. The student group South African Divestment Coalition (SADC) and its leader Matthew Lyons organized the sit-ins at Day Hall, an administrative building. Over 200 students gathered to demand that the University divest its holdings in companies doing business in apartheid South Africa. When the group refused to disperse, about 100 students were arrested.

At this point, organizer Matthew Lyons called his father David Lyons, a professor of law and philosophy at the university, for additional support. The professor helped organize the Faculty and Staff Against Apartheid (FSAA) and he, along with other staff and faculty members joined the students at Day Hall. Lyons was part of the first group of about 25 Cornell faculty and staff arrested in the divestment sit-ins. Matthew Lyons was also arrested, along with fellow student organizer Joan Meyers, and spokesperson of SADC, Kelly McGowan. All charges against them were eventually dropped, as were the charges against nearly all of those arrested, and no one was convicted.

The next week, after regrouping after the arrests, students and faculty constructed a shantytown on the Cornell campus. They built, and many resided in, shacks made out of thin boards, cardboard, tar paper, and plastic. The protesters hoped to dramatize the residences of many living in South Africa and evoke sympathy and solidarity with the oppressed. The shacks also served as a meeting place and information center for the protesters. Students all over the country erected similar encampments following Cornell’s example.

The shantytowns were a visible reminder to the campus community that the administration had financial ties with South Africa. They were an embarrassment to the university and the administration ordered campus police to remove the encampments. Students, however, simply rebuilt the towns every time they were destroyed. Events such as these seemed to have reinforced the movement, rather than stop it.

In the following weeks, at least five student groups at Cornell went on hunger strikes, 250 faculty members signed and published a petition in the student newspaper, Faculty and Staff Against Apartheid drafted documents including “Why Cornell Should Divest” and a response to the Proxy Review Committee Report on divestment, and there was a 323-73 vote at a Faculty Senate meeting in favor of total divestment. The Board of Trustees, however, was not receptive. Soon after the sit-ins began, Cornell President Frank Rhodes told a group of protesters that the trustees believed investing in socially responsible corporations doing business in South Africa was the best way to aid non-white South Africans.

The students continued occupying the shantytowns until May 11 when a fire erupted and destroyed three of the shanties. The University closed down the shantytowns and ordered them to be destroyed again. When students and faculty refused to leave, they were forcefully dragged from the area and many were arrested. Over 1,000 students, faculty, and staff would ultimately be arrested for the divestment sit-ins at the university. The students left for summer vacation hoping that their efforts during that spring would have a lasting effect on the trustee’s decisions.

Despite the efforts of divestment proponents, Cornell’s Board of Trustees refused to modify their investments and business ties with South Africa throughout the summer and fall of 1985. By 1986, faced again with student opposition, the trustees relented somewhat and adopted a policy of selective divestment. That year, the University held about $146 million of stock in companies doing business in South Africa; by late 1988, the figure had dropped to about $42 million. In January 1989, despite weekly divestment pickets the previous fall, the trustees declined to reduce the University's South African holdings further. The question became moot in the next year as the South African government began to reform and the apartheid system was dismantled.

Although the trustees did not completely divest from South Africa and the protesters could only claim at best a partial victory, the public protests had far reaching implications. It brought people together for a common cause and enabled them to become involved in the larger divestment movement. The sit-ins were the largest, most sustained student political movement in the history of Cornell. While its overall effect on the movement can be debated, what began as a protest turned into one of the most dramatic public demonstrations in Cornell’s history.

Influences

The Cornell sit-ins were part of a series of divestment movements across college campuses during 1985 (1).

The Cornell student organizers were the first to build and live in mock shantytowns during their demonstrations, a new technique that gained popularity with university divestment campaigns across the nation (2).

Sources

Kearnes, Kathleen. “Shantytown Revisited: Remembering the South African Divestment Protests of 1985 and 1986.” Cornell Alumni Magazine. March – April 2006.

Singer, Sara. “Any Person, Any Protest.” Cornell Daily Sun. 26 Feb. 2009.

Soule, Sarah. “The Effect of Student Protest on the Diffusion of University Divestment Decisions in the United States.” Cornell University Dissertation, 2008.

Name of researcher, and date dd/mm/yyyy

Meghan Auker Becker, 07/02/2010